briandevans c8ecb56f27 fix(cli): reject invalid argv values from -p/--profile before resolving ...

`_apply_profile_override()` scans `sys.argv` for `-p / --profile` at
module import time. When `hermes_cli.main` is imported inside pytest
with `-p no:xdist` on the command line, it picks up `'no:xdist'` as a
profile name candidate, then passes it to `resolve_profile_env()` which
raises `ValueError` (invalid format), and the function calls
`sys.exit(1)` — aborting test collection with an INTERNALERROR before
any test runs.

The same conflict affects any tool or wrapper that uses `-p` for its
own flag and then imports `hermes_cli.main`.

Fix: add a format guard immediately after step 1 (explicit flag scan).
If `consume == 2` (the value came from `-p <value>`, not
`--profile=value`) and the candidate doesn't match the canonical
profile-name pattern `[a-z0-9][a-z0-9_-]{0,63}` (mirrored from
`hermes_cli.profiles._PROFILE_ID_RE`), discard it and continue as if
no `-p` flag was found. The `active_profile` file-based fallback
(step 2) only reads a file written by hermes itself, so it always
produces valid names and needs no guard.

Regression guard: with the guard reverted, importing
`hermes_cli.main` with `sys.argv = ['pytest', '-p', 'no:xdist', ...]`
raises `SystemExit(1)`. With the guard in place, the import succeeds
and `sys.argv` is left intact for pytest. Legitimate `-p coder` still
flows through to `resolve_profile_env()` unchanged.

Rebased onto current `origin/main` (`e5dad4ac5`) — the prior branch
base (`4fade39c9`) was 824 commits behind and the PR was DIRTY /
CONFLICTING. The 1.5 HERMES_HOME-set early-return block has since
landed between the original insertion point and step 2; the new guard
is positioned correctly before the early return so a bogus `-p` value
no longer prevents the early return from kicking in.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

2026-05-04 03:11:47 -07:00

388 KiB

Raw Blame History

View Raw